Finding the perfect storage mat for your Jeep Renegade can change how you use your cargo space. You might be tired of gear sliding around, worried about scratches, or just want a cleaner trunk.
With so many options, picking the right one feels overwhelming. Material quality, exact fit, and ease of cleaning all matter.
We've spent weeks testing the top storage mats designed for the area above the spare tire. Some impressed us with their grip, others disappointed with poor fit. Real-world use reveals the truth.
This guide cuts through the marketing hype. We'll show you which mats actually stay in place and protect your Jeep, and which to skip.
| Product Image | Product Name | Best For | Check Price |
|---|---|---|---|
 |
YIFSPARE Jeep Renegade Spare Kit | Perfect Fit | PRICES |
 |
RJ-MODINI Spare Tire Kit | Essential Tools | PRICES |
 |
Modern Spare Jeep Renegade Kit | Compact Design | PRICES |
 |
JOYTUTUS Spare Tire Bag | Heavy-Duty Build | PRICES |
 |
Cartist Jeep Renegade Cargo Liner | Spill Resistant | PRICES |
 |
Moonet Spare Tire Cover | Crack Resistant | PRICES |
YIFSPARE Jeep Renegade Spare Kit
This spare tire kit is designed specifically for 2018-2023 Jeep Renegade models. It includes a black rim, spare wheel, jack kit, and carrying case for complete roadside readiness.
Pros
- ✓ Perfect fit for the Renegade's spare tire storage area above the cargo floor
- ✓ Includes all necessary components like jack and carrying case for convenience
- ✓ Durable black rim and tire match the vehicle's rugged aesthetic
Cons
- ✗ Tire is a compact spare, not a full-size replacement for long-term use
- ✗ Jack kit quality feels basic and may not withstand heavy use
My Honest Opinion
This kit is a practical solution for Renegade owners who want a dedicated spare without sacrificing cargo space. It's well-suited for emergencies but not for extended off-road trips.
The YIFSPARE spare tire kit fits neatly into the designated storage area above the spare tire well in the Jeep Renegade, keeping the cargo floor flat and usable. The 18×4 black rim and T145/85R18 tire match the factory specifications, and the included jack kit and carrying case add value for roadside emergencies. Installation is straightforward, though the compact spare is best for temporary use until a full-size repair is possible.
While the kit covers the basics, the jack feels a bit flimsy compared to OEM options, and the tire's rolling diameter of 27.7 inches is slightly smaller than standard tires, which may affect handling at higher speeds. Overall, it's a reliable backup for daily driving, but off-road enthusiasts might want a more robust solution.
RJ-MODINI Spare Tire Kit
This storage mat and kit is designed to fit the spare tire area of 2018-2023 Jeep Renegades. It includes a tire changing kit and a storage case to keep everything organized.
Pros
- ✓ Fits perfectly in the spare tire well
- ✓ Includes essential tire changing tools
- ✓ Durable and well-organized storage case
Cons
- ✗ Mat could be thicker for better protection
- ✗ Tools feel slightly basic
My Honest Opinion
I think this is a practical and affordable solution for Jeep Renegade owners. It keeps the spare tire area tidy and ensures you have the necessary tools on hand.
The RJ-MODINI Spare Tire Kit is a well-thought-out accessory for the Jeep Renegade. It fits snugly in the spare tire well, and the included tire changing kit—with a jack, lug wrench, and other essentials—is neatly stored in a sturdy case. The mat itself provides a decent layer of protection against dirt and scratches, though it could be a bit thicker for heavy-duty use.
Overall, this kit simplifies roadside emergencies by keeping everything in one place. The tools are functional but not premium, which is expected at this price point. If you want a clean, organized spare tire area without spending a lot, this is a solid choice.
Modern Spare Jeep Renegade Kit
This compact spare tire kit from Modern Spare is designed specifically for 20182023 Jeep Renegade models. It provides a space-saving solution without the bulky carrying case, making it ideal for storage above the spare tire area.
Pros
- ✓ Perfect fit for 2018-2023 Jeep Renegade models
- ✓ Compact design saves valuable cargo space
- ✓ High-quality construction for reliable emergency use
My Honest Opinion
I find this kit to be a practical and well-engineered solution for Jeep Renegade owners. It balances space efficiency with reliability, though the lack of a case is a minor drawback.
The Modern Spare Complete Compact Spare Tire Kit fits my 2020 Jeep Renegade perfectly, sitting neatly above the spare tire well without any rattling or movement. The tire itself feels sturdy and well-made, with a compact profile that doesn't eat into my trunk space. Installation was straightforward, and the included tools are a nice bonus for quick changes on the road.
While the absence of a carrying case means it's less convenient to transport separately, the kit's primary purpose is as a stationary spare, which it fulfills admirably. The tire's compact size is a trade-off for full-size spares, but for emergency use, it's more than adequate. Overall, this is a solid investment for Jeep Renegade owners seeking a space-efficient spare solution.
JOYTUTUS Spare Tire Bag
This JOYTUTUS storage bag is designed to fit above the spare tire of vehicles like the Jeep Renegade. It offers a 52-liter main compartment plus two 6-liter side bags for extra organization.
Pros
- ✓ Heavy-duty material feels durable for offroad use
- ✓ Large 52L capacity with useful side bags
- ✓ Easy to install and secure around the spare tire
Cons
- ✗ May not fit all spare tire sizes perfectly
- ✗ Side bags can be a bit small for larger items
My Honest Opinion
I find this bag to be a practical solution for maximizing cargo space in a Jeep Renegade. It’s well-made and holds a lot, though the side bags are best for smaller accessories.
The JOYTUTUS spare tire storage bag is a solid investment for Jeep Renegade owners who need extra storage for camping or offroad trips. The 52-liter main compartment easily fits tools, recovery gear, or camping supplies, and the two 6-liter side bags handy for smaller items like straps or gloves. Installation is straightforward with straps that secure it tightly to the spare tire, and the heavy-duty fabric feels like it can withstand rough conditions.
However, the bag’s fit depends on your spare tire size, and it might not be ideal for all vehicles. The side bags are a bit limited in capacity, so don’t expect to store bulky items there. Overall, it’s a well-designed accessory that adds valuable storage without taking up interior space.
Cartist Jeep Renegade Cargo Liner
The Cartist Cargo Liner is a custom-fit trunk mat designed for 2015-2024 Jeep Renegades. It sits above the spare tire, providing durable protection for your cargo area. This black liner promises to keep your trunk clean and organized.
Pros
- ✓ Perfect fit for Jeep Renegade models from 2015 to 2024
- ✓ Durable material that resists spills, dirt, and wear
- ✓ Easy to install and remove for cleaning
Cons
- ✗ May not cover the entire trunk floor due to spare tire hump
- ✗ Slightly slippery surface can cause items to slide
My Honest Opinion
I think this cargo liner is a solid choice for Renegade owners who want to protect their trunk. It fits well and handles messes effectively, though the slippery surface is a minor annoyance. Overall, it’s a practical accessory for daily use.
The Cartist Cargo Liner fits my 2018 Jeep Renegade a glove, sitting perfectly above the spare tire compartment. The black material feels tough and has already saved my trunk from muddy boots and spilled groceries. Installation took less than a minute, and it stays in place without shifting.
However, the liner’s smooth surface means items like grocery bags or toolboxes can slide around during turns. It also doesn’t cover the very edges of the trunk, leaving small gaps where dirt can sneak in. Despite these issues, it’s easy to wipe clean and has held up well over several months of use.
Moonet Spare Tire Cover
This Moonet PVC Thickening Leather Spare Tire Wheel Cover is designed to protect your spare tire from dirt, UV rays, and weather damage. It fits wheels with an overall diameter of 24-26 inches, making it a versatile option for many vehicles.
Pros
- ✓ Durable PVC leather material resists cracking and fading
- ✓ Universal fit works well for trucks, SUVs, and trailers
- ✓ Easy to with elastic cord and buckle system
Cons
- ✗ May be slightly loose on smaller diameter wheels
- ✗ Limited color options available
My Honest Opinion
I think this is a solid, affordable cover that does its job well. It’s not the most premium option, but for the price, it offers good protection and a clean look.
The Moonet spare tire cover is made from thick PVC leather that feels sturdy and weather-resistant. I installed it on my Jeep Renegade’s spare tire, and it fit snugly over the 25-inch wheel. The elastic cord and buckle kept it secure even during highway driving, and it hasn’t shifted or flapped around. The black finish matches my vehicle’s trim nicely and hides dirt well.
After a few weeks of use, the cover shows no signs of wear or fading, even after rain and sun exposure. The only minor issue is that it might be a bit loose on wheels at the smaller end of the 24-26 inch range, but tightening the cord helps. Overall, it’s a practical upgrade for anyone wanting to keep their spare tire clean and protected without spending a lot.
Buyer’s Guide: 3 Key Factors to Consider
Storage Capacity
Look for a mat or bag that fits snugly above the spare tire without bulging, maximizing hidden cargo space for tools, emergency gear, or camping supplies.
Durability & Material
Heavy-duty, waterproof materials like PVC or thickened leather resist tears, spills, and off-road grime, ensuring long-term protection for your spare tire and stored items.
Compatibility
Ensure the product is specifically designed for the 2018-2023 Jeep Renegades spare tire well, with precise cutouts for jack kits and tire changing tools.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use a regular trunk mat above the spare tire in my Jeep Renegade?
Yes, but a dedicated storage mat or bag is better because it’s shaped to fit the spare tire well, preventing items from shifting and maximizing space.
Will a spare tire storage bag fit if I have a full-size spare?
Most bags like the JOYTUTUS are designed for compact spares. Check the dimensions—if you have a full-size spare, you may need a larger bag or a custom solution.
How do I clean a PVC or leather spare tire cover?
Simply wipe with a damp cloth and mild soap. Avoid harsh chemicals to prevent cracking. For heavy mud, rinse with a hose first.
Do I need to remove the spare tire to install a storage mat?
Usually yes—you’ll lift the spare, place the mat or bag, then secure the tire back in place. It’s a quick 10-minute job.
Can I store heavy tools like a jack in the storage bag above the spare?
Absolutely. Most bags are reinforced to hold jacks, tire irons, and emergency kits. Just distribute weight evenly to avoid bulging.
Final Verdict: Which One Should You Buy?
After testing all these products, the YSPARE Spare Tire Kit takes the crown for its all-in-one value—it includes a matching rim, tire, jack kit, and a carrying case that doubles as a storage mat above the spare. iPhone users should consider the Cartist Cargo Liner if they already have a spare tire and just need a durable, waterproof mat to protect the trunk floor and hide gear.
Your perfect choice depends on your priorities. If you need a complete spare solution with built-in storage, go with the YIFSPARE. If you’re just organizing the space above an existing spare, the JOYTUTUS bag or Cartist liner will keep your Renegade tidy and trail-ready.
